Sin Evasión / Without Evasion

English translation of Miriam Celaya's blog "Sin EVAsión" from Havana, Cuba

The pleasure of controversy

 

melia_cohiba

I’ve waited several days before commenting on the debate that ensued among readers on my post titled “Don’t lecture us”; urgent matters had me prioritize other posts. However, I don’t want to miss out on the opportunity to return to that issue. I was hoping, indeed, that it would be as controversial as it turned out, but some comments have brought to the surface certain doubts I want to clarify: I have never shown or felt hatred for Zapatero, nor have I ever questioned the right of Spanish voters to elect him president, I am glad that there are countries where people have the opportunity to elect democratically (an unknown experience for millions of Cubans) and furthermore, I am glad that citizens allow themselves to criticize the elected leader’s performance. However, for my part, I reserve the slightest right to question, at least, the dealings of any public official, from whatever country he may be, especially if he proclaims intentions that he doesn’t carry out de facto. I do not recall having mentioned Zapatero, but you can be sure that if I deemed it necessary to disagree with his position in any matter related to Cuba -as was the case with Moratinos- I would, even if he had been elected by the totality of Spanish voters as a whole. I don’t think I will ask permission to voice my opinion.

As for the fact that I, as a blogger, took a reader’s comment as reference, does not seem so special nor is it a particular honor, as some seemed to think, but it is a natural consequence of the debate that has been pursued in this blog, where I don’t intend to impose ranks or castes. I write with the same willfulness with which you read and comment, and I submit to my readers’ trial, criticism or questioning with each post I upload, offering my name and face to the public, so why shouldn’t I discuss or comment on certain readers’ criteria that move me to reply?

And since I don’t wish that anyone should suggest a tone of xenophobia on my part either, I insist that my evaluation of Spanish companies -among others- as “bandits,” comes from the in-depth knowledge that I have of the conditions of employment and wages Cubans that work for them are paid. There are not bandits because they are Spanish… but they are bandits indeed. To my knowledge, ALL foreign firms that invest in Cuba or contract Cuban personnel recruited from their respective countries, harbor and apply the draconian conditions of the contracts for nationals, knowing that, by doing so, they are violating major agreements of the International Labor Organization. And here I want to insert a proactive patch, the fact that this happens not only in Cuba, and that other sub-developed countries may suffer the same wrong, does not change the essence of my complaint. However, these investors are bypassing such “trifles” because Cubans are good workers and the contractors –such as the Cuban government- have obtained large profits in these dealings… Profits that now, ironically, are partially confiscated in the gaunt vaults of Cuban banks.

Similarly, foreign firms may impose unfair working hours because they know that the Cuban under contract, unprotected by any trade union, will be compelled to accept them or be turned out onto the streets, while dozens of other Cubans stand on line awaiting to be hired instead, to get at least a small amount of foreign currency with which to gain access to essential consumer goods. It is not mere sentimentality; it’s the stark reality. So it is that the so-called foreign “companies” have been contributing also to the “anthropological damage” that the renowned Cuban intellectual, Dagoberto Valdés, director of the digital magazine Coexistence, once defined.

I have reason to know of these maneuvers, and believe me, to share in them because they allegedly constitute a source of opportunity for Cubans is almost equivalent to justifying child pornography: “what the heck, those children were starving and their own parents sold them off”. Yes, I responsibly evaluate those Spanish companies and the rest of them as “bandits”, and I stand by it.

Finally, I support and encourage the participation of people of all nationalities in this humble forum, but I will not accept that my answer or response to any commentary be deemed as a special honor or as an exception; it is not about flattery or personal attack either. I feel close enough to the readers as to consider myself one of them. I tend to read each entry carefully and, as far as my limited Internet access permits, I respond to the e-mails I receive. Many readers can attest to that. Finally, I never tried to make anyone feel uncomfortable by bringing him into the ring -my sincere apologies to the reader that saw it that way- at the end of the day, I am the one who places herself permanently under the readers’ demanding magnifying glass, and I don’t flinch. Nor can I commit myself to never to do again: I avoid making promises that, in advance, I know I could not fulfill. Come on, friends, we are not among bandits in this blog!

3 Comentarios »

  Franzi escrito @ Diciembre 7th, 2009 at 4:45 AM

Penso, che il tuo grido di basta, insieme a tanti altri giovani cubani e non, che oggi in tutto il mondo si alza contro queste oligarchie dilaganti, sia l’unica forma oggi, per risvegliare le coscienza e dire basta!! a governi che usano il loro potere anzichè per favorire lo sviluppo del proprio paese e il benessere dei suoi concittadini, per sottometterli e toglierli i loro diritto naturale, di uomini liberi. ! Avanti!!! coraggio, ne abbiamo bisogno tutti.

  Humberto Capiro escrito @ Diciembre 11th, 2009 at 10:33 PM

GUARDIAN UK ARTICLE:Castro supporters clash with Cuban dissidents on human rights marches
Pro-government groups target relatives calling for liberty of Cuban political prisoners

“Hundreds of government supporters have jostled and jeered Cuban dissidents who staged two small marches in Havana to mark Human Rights Day.

The crowds, who chanted pro-Castro slogans, also targeted a British diplomat who attended the smaller of the two marches as an observer, surrounding and banging on his car until police intervened.

The incidents happened yesterday after a 30-strong group of female relatives of political prisoners ‑ known as “the ladies in white” ‑ marched through the capital chanting “liberty”. They carried flowers, Cuban flags and copies of the universal declaration of human rights.

A crowd of about 250 people surrounded them and shouted “traitors” and “the street belongs to Fidel”, a reference to the communist leader who ceded power last year to his brother Raul.

“How can it be possible that they won’t let us walk in the streets on this day?” Melba Santana Ariz, whose husband has been held as a political prisoner since 2003, told Reuters. “There are no human rights here.”"

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/dec/11/castro-supporters-clash-cuban-dissidents

  Humberto Capiro escrito @ Diciembre 12th, 2009 at 12:26 AM

NEW YORK TIMES: Cuba Detains a U.S. Contractor

HAVANA — A United States government contract worker, who was distributing cellphones, laptops and other communications equipment in Cuba on behalf of the Obama administration, has been detained by the authorities here, American officials said Friday.

Cuba has allowed more citizens than ever to buy cellphones and computers, but even the limited access to digital technology that is available has created problems for the government. Cuban officials have shown particular concern about Yoani Sánchez, a prominent government critic who keeps in touch with thousands of followers with a blog and a Twitter account.

Recently, the Cuban government denied Ms. Sánchez a visa to accept a prestigious journalism award in New York. President Obama has also made a guest appearance on her blog, sending written answers to questions she submitted to him.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/12/world/americas/12cuba.html

Su comentario

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


  Trad. ForodeFotos